Performance Solution and Deemed-to-Satisfy, the difference

The code sets the outcome a building has to achieve. You can follow its prescribed route, or prove that another route gets there.

What is the difference between a Performance Solution and a Deemed-to-Satisfy Solution?

Both are ways to comply with the National Construction Code. A Deemed-to-Satisfy Solution follows the code's prescriptive provisions and is taken to comply. A Performance Solution takes another route and has to be shown, through an accepted Assessment Method, to satisfy the Performance Requirements. One building can use both.

The National Construction Code gives two ways to show that a building complies. You can follow its Deemed-to-Satisfy Provisions, which spell out what to build, or you can design a Performance Solution and prove it achieves the required outcome. A project can use either one for each requirement, and most buildings end up with a mix.

Underneath both sit the Performance Requirements. They are the only mandatory part of the code, and they describe outcomes rather than methods, such as a building that holds back the spread of fire long enough for the people inside to get out.

Deemed-to-Satisfy

The Deemed-to-Satisfy Provisions, or DTS, are the prescriptive part of the code. They set out materials, dimensions, fire resistance levels, the number and position of exits, and the Australian Standards to follow.

A design that follows the DTS provisions for a requirement is deemed to satisfy the Performance Requirement behind it. The certifier checks the design against the provisions, and no further proof is needed. That predictability is why so much of an ordinary building is DTS, because it is simple to design, to price and to certify.

Performance Solution

A Performance Solution is any other way of satisfying a Performance Requirement. It is used when the DTS provisions do not describe what is being built, or when following them would take away something the project needs.

The code lists the Assessment Methods that can prove a solution works: evidence of suitability, a Verification Method, expert judgement, or a comparison with the DTS provisions. Evidence of suitability can be a test report from an accredited laboratory, a CodeMark certificate or a certificate from a professional engineer.

Who prepares it and who accepts it

Fire safety is a common place for Performance Solutions, and those are prepared by a fire safety engineer. The work starts with a performance-based design brief agreed with the people who have a stake in the outcome. Analysis follows, then a report showing how the solution satisfies each Performance Requirement it addresses.

The certifier decides whether to accept it. In NSW the Performance Solution is documented with the construction certificate application, so it is settled before construction is approved, as covered in what is a Construction Certificate in NSW.

How it applies to a modular building

The code has no separate rulebook for a building made in a factory. The same Performance Requirements apply to a module as to conventional in-situ work, and the hybrid build changes how the factory and the site work together to satisfy them, not the bar itself.

Where a factory-built detail follows a DTS provision, it is certified the same way it would be on any site. Where a detail such as the junction between two modules sits outside what the DTS provisions describe, it is designed and proven as a Performance Solution with evidence. Fire and sound separation at those junctions is covered in how is fire and acoustic performance achieved in modular construction.

On special-use accommodation

Our special-use work spans Class 1a, 2 and 3, and a Class 3 building carries more demanding fire and egress requirements than a house. The class sets which provisions apply, as explained in NCC building classes for special-use accommodation.

A Performance Solution belongs to the code. The SDA Design Standard is a separate document assessed by an accredited SDA assessor, so the two are worked through side by side. Our co-founder is an ACAA Accredited Access Consultant, an NDIS Accredited SDA Assessor, an LHA and NCC Assessor and a Changing Places Assessor, so both readings sit inside the design from the first stage.

Which one to use

DTS is the default because it is the simplest to prove. A Performance Solution earns its place when it protects something the project needs, such as an open plan that suits the residents, and the evidence for it is planned before the design depends on it.

MADEmodular / MADEbetter.

Our standards. Discuss your project.

MADEmodular / MADEbetter.

Let's talk.

Special-use accommodation, made better.