Lump sum and cost plus contracts, the difference

The two contracts answer one question differently. Who pays when the work costs more than expected?

What is the difference between a lump sum and a cost plus contract?

A lump sum contract sets one price for a defined scope of work, so the builder carries the risk of that work costing more. A cost plus contract pays the builder's actual costs plus an agreed fee, so the owner carries that risk. A lump sum price moves only through variations, provisional sums and events the contract allows.

Under a lump sum contract the builder agrees one price for a defined scope of work, while under a cost plus contract the owner pays whatever the work actually costs, plus a fee. Both are common in Australian construction.

The real difference is who carries the risk of the cost growing. Under a lump sum it sits mostly with the builder, and under cost plus it sits with the owner.

How a lump sum works

The builder prices the drawings and the specification and commits to that figure. If labour or materials cost more than the builder allowed, the builder absorbs the difference, and if the builder works efficiently, the saving is the builder's.

That gives the owner a known number for the work described. It also puts weight on the documents, because the price covers only what they show.

How cost plus works

Under cost plus, the owner pays the actual cost of labour, materials and subcontractors, backed by invoices and timesheets, plus the builder's fee. The fee can be a fixed amount or a percentage of the cost.

It suits work that cannot be fully described before it starts, such as repairs where the damage is unknown until the building is opened up. The owner gets flexibility and full sight of the costs, and in exchange carries every increase.

Some contracts sit between the two. Under cost plus with an agreed ceiling, the owner pays actual cost up to that maximum and the builder carries anything above it.

What still moves a lump sum

A fixed price is fixed for the scope in the contract, not for anything the owner asks for later. A variation is a change to that scope, and it is priced and agreed as it arises.

Provisional sums and prime cost items move the final figure too. A provisional sum is an allowance for work that could not be priced when the contract was signed, and a prime cost item is an allowance for a fitting or finish not yet chosen. When the real cost is known, the contract price is adjusted up or down.

Latent conditions, such as rock or contamination found in the ground, are handled however the contract says. Each of these is a place where a fixed price can grow, so the number of allowances in a contract says a lot about how fixed the price really is.

What a lender looks for

A financier funding construction wants to know the cost to complete. A lump sum with a complete scope and few allowances answers that question most directly.

The lender's quantity surveyor checks the contract against the budget before the facility is agreed. The lender's wider view is set out in what de-risks a modular project for a financier, and how the budget holds money for unknowns is covered in what is a construction contingency.

Where certainty comes from

A fixed price is only as firm as the design beneath it. Our price is locked before we start, because the work that settles it comes first, with the site and the compliance pathway tested at feasibility and the design resolved through eight stages before any module is made.

Every decision closed on paper is one less allowance carried into the contract. The factors that set a price in the first place are covered in what moves a price on a modular project.

One contract from design to handover

The gap between one party's drawings and another party's price is where many variations begin. With one accountable business from design through to handover, under one contract, a gap in the drawings does not turn into a dispute between two contracts, as explained in what does design and construct delivery actually mean.

MADEmodular / MADEbetter.

How we deliver. Discuss your project.

MADEmodular / MADEbetter.

Let's talk.

Special-use accommodation, made better.